【超市大搜查】《LDK》實測16款洗潔精 清潔力+除菌力+不傷手度大比拼【附詳細名單】
發布時間: 2021/09/29 12:49
最後更新: 2023/09/20 19:40
▲ 16款洗潔精清潔力+除菌力+不傷手度大比拼。
家家必備洗潔精,到底哪一款洗潔精清潔力足夠又可除菌、不傷手?日本雜誌《LDK》仔細評測了16款洗潔精的清潔力、除菌力、不傷手度及泡沫持久度,當中包括多個知名品牌,如獅王、花王、大創等。發現原來標榜除菌的洗潔精除菌力不一定夠強、標榜溫和的洗潔精亦可傷手,馬上看看評測結果!
最新影片:
《LDK》仔細評測了16款洗潔精的清潔力、除菌力、不傷手度及泡沫持久度,品牌包括:獅王、花王、大創、P&G。評測方法及準則如下:
清潔力:將紅色特殊油脂塗在透明板上,然後測重量。使用規定份量的洗潔清,用專用機器清洗。自然晾乾後,再測重量,計算出清潔力比率。
除菌力:測試可消除多少「金黃葡萄球菌」及「大腸杆菌」。將洗潔精加入培養了「金黃葡萄球菌」的培養皿,如具高殺菌力,可將「金黃葡萄球菌」徹底清除。至於測試「大腸杆菌」,則將浸過洗潔精的紙,放在培養皿中。如殺菌力高,紙周圍的細菌會消失;殺菌力低,細菌則不會消失。
不傷手度:用類似手部皮膚蛋白質的蛋清,與洗潔精混合,放過夜,然後檢查變性程度。另檢查洗潔精成分及流動性,以了解洗潔精屬於「弱鹼性」、「中性」或是「弱酸性」。
泡沫持久度:海綿沾取規定份量的洗潔精,揉出柔軟泡沫,然後加1克油,再次揉搓,觀察泡沫是否減少。一直重複加油,直至不再起泡。
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/429092_600.jpg)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/429203_600.jpg)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/429204_600.jpg)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/429191_600.jpg)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/429193_600.jpg)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/429220_600.jpg)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/429237_600.jpg)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/429239_600.jpg)
評測結果:
第16位至第10位
評測結果處於下位圈的洗潔精,大多屬於4個範疇均表現一般的產品,當中有除菌力較差的洗潔精,亦有較為傷手的洗潔精。部份產品於本港有售。
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/46_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/47_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/48_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/43_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/44_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/45_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/40_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/41_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/42_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/37_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/38_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/39_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/34_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/35_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/36_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/31_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/32_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/33_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/28_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/29_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/30_600.png)
第8位至第1位
至於評分較好的洗潔精,一般屬於有1、2個範疇表現尤其突出,例如清潔力強勁、除菌力強勁或可呵護雙手。至於16款中,《LDK》最推薦的洗潔精為「日本獅王媽媽濃縮洗潔精」。因其可徹底去除污垢和細菌,泡沫持久度不錯,價格較便宜,對皮膚也較溫和。不過《LDK》重申,每個人對洗潔精的需求不一,故排名第2或更低的洗潔精,依然可納入大家的購買清單。
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/25_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/26_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/27_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/24_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/23_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/22_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/19_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/20_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/21_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/16_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/17_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/18_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/13_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/14_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/15_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/10_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/11_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/12_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/7_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/8_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/9_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/4_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/5_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/6_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/1_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/2_600.png)
![](https://static04.hket.com/res/v3/image/content/3065000/3069780/3_600.png)
責任編輯:羅嘉欣